Album Of The Year brings all that is the sound of The Good Life to fruition: catchy, moody pop/rock that fluctuates between the all-ages club and the smoky cabaret, right alongside sing-along crescendos that spin into cinematic bursts. It also proved to be The Good Life's most critically acclaimed album to date. Pitchfork gave it an 8.0, while AP called it one of the 10 essential albums of 2004.

1. Album of the Year

2. Night and Day

3. Under a Honeymoon

4. You're No Fool

5. Notes in His Pockets

6. You're Not You

7. October Leaves

8. Lovers Need Lawyers

9. Inmates

10. Needy

11. A New Friend

12. Two Years This Month