The band's debut, 2005's This Could Be a Possibility, was overall a good album, displaying themes and vibes that brought back memories of quality pop-punk, but their Columbia Records debut, We All Need a Reason to Believe takes the Philadelphia quintet's sound to the next level. Produced by Ariel Rechtshaid (We Are Scientists, Plain White T's), We All Need a Reason to Believe features eleven tracks that are fast, raw, and pack an emotional punch the majority of the bands in the genre fail to generate.